| Platinum | Allegory |
| Gold | Catch 35 Naperville |
| Silver | Meatheads Burgers & Fries |
| Bronze | Hugo’s Frog Bar & Fish House |
| Top Pick | Butterfield's Pancake House |
| Top Pick | Buttermilk |
| Top Pick | Empire Burgers & Brew |
| Top Pick | Everdine's Grilled Cheese Co. |
| Top Pick | Nature's Best Cafe |
| Top Pick | SugarToad Restaurant |