| Platinum | VAI's Italian Inspired Kitchen + Bar |
| Gold | La Sorella di Francesca |
| Silver | Rosebud Restaurants |
| Bronze | Little Italian Pizza |
| Top Pick | Braconi's Restaurant & Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Clara's |
| Top Pick | Fiamme |
| Top Pick | Fontano's Subs |
| Top Pick | Little Pops Pizzeria |
| Rosati's Pizza |