| Platinum | Little Pops Pizzeria |
| Gold | Little Italian Pizza |
| Silver | Giordano's |
| Bronze | Rosati's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Adamo's Pizza & Catering |
| Top Pick | Fiamme |
| Top Pick | Old Town Pizza |
| Top Pick | Rocco's Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Rosebud Restaurants |
| Top Pick | Uncle Pete's Pizza |
| CiCi's Pizza |