| Platinum | Little Pops Pizzeria |
| Gold | Rosebud |
| Silver | VAI's Italian Inspired Kitchen + Bar |
| Bronze | Angeli's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Clara's |
| Top Pick | Fontanos Subs |
| Top Pick | Fontina's Italian Kitchen |
| Top Pick | La Sorella di Francesca |
| Top Pick | Little Italian Pizza |
| Top Pick | Traversos Restaurant |